What would you change?

Live forum: http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=200

katana109794

30-04-2005 16:58:18

Curious if someone to make a NIMH 3 or remake 1...linotices the members of the broad drawing swords, cocking guns, and other various implements of painli let me explain myself.

If you were put in charge of NIMH 3 or had to remake the first one what would you add or take away?
For one I would try to make the story be as gripping as the first one and distance it from the abomination that was the 2nd one. Also I would hint or rather show that Mrs. Brisby and Justin are a couple but I would make their relationship grow as opposed to they just start kissing and such the first time they see each other. Also I would try to make the villian someone you love to hate, like Jenner. Any other ideas?

RustedWolf Fox

30-04-2005 18:10:37

I wouldn't even bother making the third, and the only thing I'd probably add in the first is getting deeper into the relationship between Justin and Mrs. Brisby.

Simon

30-04-2005 18:20:13

See these threads for some previous discussion along these lines:
http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=122
http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=16
http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5
http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=60
http://www.thornvalley.com/commons/forum/viewtopic.php?t=38

And maybe I'm missing something, but there never is a kissing scene between Justin and Mrs. Brisby in the movie. Or are you talking about this theoretical 'remake'?

katana109794

01-05-2005 15:19:29

I meant in the theoretical remake. They seemed to have good chemistry enough to justify it.
But like I said in my version it would grow and the power of the stone wouldn't just appear out of nowhere at the last second. It felt like Don couldn't think up a logical way to end the Brisby's moving troubles so he just threw in some all powerful deus ex machina and that gave him enough to get him into the end.
Although I still think that Mrs. Brisby would have been very cute with Justin. After all she gave him her most treasured and powerful item to him. You wouldn't just hand something like that over to just anybody.

HolyArrow

31-05-2005 14:02:10

Well, I would use better quality for the movie (That's one thing a really disliked from NIMH 2) and also I would throw away the "NIMH" scene and make a larger one and have Johnathan speak. I also want a scene with Mrs. B and Johnathan together in some way, like Mrs. Brisby thinking of when they were together, etc. Basically, I want Johnathan to be a major character. :D

mythril

01-07-2005 18:36:17

i think the first is good the way it is. i would redo the sequal and give it a better story line and better animation.